Free tool

Excel, ERP or Workflow? Find What Your CNC Shop Needs

Answer ten plain questions about how your shop ran in the last month. The tool tells you whether Excel is enough, an ERP is the move, a system built around your floor fits, or a few agreements need settling first. It names no products and asks for no sign-up.

  • 10 questions
  • About 3 minutes
  • Nothing is sent
Start the check or press Try an example to see a finished answer.

The full reasoning, with when each option is the right answer: Excel vs ERP vs a Workflow System.

Your result appears below the questions, and in a bar at the bottom while you answer.

Think of the last month. Answer what you can: Not sure is allowed, but it does not count. Saved on this device as you go, never sent to us.

0 of 10

1. Your shop

What fits depends on size as well as habits.

How many machines does the shop run?

2. Agreements

Yes means it is in place today.

Is there a written rule for when a job may be released to the floor?
Yes = in place
Does one named person decide when a priority changes?
Yes = in place
Is someone responsible for updating job status during the shift, and does it happen?
Yes = in place

3. Office side

Yes means it happened in the last month.

In the last month, did a material or stock surprise hold up a job, because stock and purchase orders sit in different files?
Yes = it happened
Is the same order typed into more than one place (Tally, Excel, WhatsApp), with copies that disagree?
Yes = it happened
Is it hard to trace a quote, cost or invoice back to the job it came from?
Yes = it happened

4. Floor side

Yes means it happened in the last month.

Did a job sit somewhere with nobody named as responsible for it?
Yes = it happened
Is your plan or job status out of date by mid-morning?
Yes = it happened
Did priorities change several times in a single shift?
Yes = it happened
Does the shop slow down or stop when one particular person is away?
Yes = it happened
How many people update the plan or job status?

5. What you run on

What do you run on today? (tick all that apply, optional)

Finished? Clear all answers from this device.

How this decides

The tool counts three things from your answers: office-side problems (the first three questions), floor-side problems (the next four, plus one if four or more people update the plan) and how many of the three agreements are in place. It then checks, in this order, and stops at the first that fits:

  1. 1. Not enough to say

    Fewer than 7 of the 10 questions answered with Yes or No ("Not sure" does not count).

  2. 2. Excel is enough

    No more than 1 office-side and no more than 1 floor-side problem.

  3. 3. Rules first

    Two or more floor-side problems, and at most one of the three agreements in place. The result you would otherwise get is shown as "then".

  4. 4. A system built around your floor

    Two or more floor-side problems, and not two or more office-side ones.

  5. 5. An ERP is the move

    Two or more office-side problems, and not two or more floor-side ones.

  6. 6. Both sides, in order

    Two or more of each.

When the deciding count is exactly 2, the result says it is a close call and names the cheaper thing to try first. These are rules of thumb from how shop floors behave, not a standard or a statistical model, and the tool knows only what you tell it. We build workflow systems, so check this logic: it can, and often does, say Excel or an ERP is the better choice. A tool sees only what you tell it, and only today. Seeing how jobs really move on your floor is what our Operational Workflow Review looks at.

Common questions

Is Excel an ERP tool?

No. Excel is a spreadsheet. For a small shop it can hold orders, a plan and simple costing, and it can stand in for part of what an ERP does while one person keeps it current. An ERP is a connected system for orders, stock, purchasing and accounts that several people update at once. This tool tells you when Excel stops being enough in your shop, and what to do instead. Excel vs ERP vs a Workflow System.

Is ERP outdated?

No. An ERP is still the right tool for orders, stock, purchasing and accounts. What it does not do on its own is decide when a job is released, who may change a priority, or what runs next on each machine. That is why a shop can own an ERP and still run its floor from a whiteboard or a spreadsheet. Why ERP Systems Don't Fix Operational Chaos in CNC Shops.

What software is used in manufacturing?

It depends on the job. Shops commonly use accounts software such as Tally for accounts and GST, spreadsheets for planning and quotes, an ERP for orders, stock and purchasing, and sometimes a system for live job status on the floor. This tool does not recommend products. It tells you which kind of tool your problems point to, so you can ask suppliers the right questions.

What is a workflow system?

A small application that holds your own shop's rules for moving a job from order to dispatch: when it is released, who owns it at each step, who may change its priority. It shows everyone the same current picture. It is not an ERP and is not meant to replace one: it works alongside your accounts software or ERP.

Why does the tool sometimes say "rules first"?

When the pain is on the floor and most of three agreements are missing (when a job is released, who changes a priority, who updates status), a new system would only record the confusion faster. Agreeing them is quick, and it makes whichever tool you choose work. If you have them, the tool says so and moves on to the system.

Is anything I type saved or sent to you?

No. The tool runs in your browser. We only count that it was used (a result shown, printed or shared, or the "talk to us" button tapped), never what you typed. What you type is kept on your own device so a refresh does not lose it; Start fresh clears it. The one exception is your own choice: the "talk to us" button opens WhatsApp with a message you can read and edit, and it is sent only if you press send. On a shared computer, press Start fresh when you finish.

More free tools

All free tools →

Want someone to look at your floor?

The check works from what you tell it. On a free 90-minute floor walk we look at how jobs actually move, where they wait, and tell you plainly what to fix first, whether or not it involves us.

Book a free floor walk
Book a free floor walk
expand_less